Share this article
Coinbase-Led Group Aims to Help Crypto Firms Avoid Securities Violations
Coinbase, Circle, Genesis and more are developing a ratings system aimed to flag crypto assets that are similar to securities.
Updated Sep 13, 2021, 11:30 a.m. Published Sep 30, 2019, 1:05 p.m.
Crypto industry leaders are taking the initiative to help firms in the space avoid running afoul of securities rules.
In a company blog post, Coinbase announced it has co-founded the Crypto Rating Council, a member organization purposed with assisting cryptocurrency companies determine if they comply with current U.S. federal securities law.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW
Don't miss another story.Subscribe to the Crypto Daybook Americas Newsletter today. See all newsletters
Coinbase is joined at launch by seven other firms: Anchorage, Bittrex, Circle, DRW Cumberland, Genesis, Grayscale Investments and Kraken.
As part of the effort, the council will issue a 1–5 rating for a given cryptocurrency or token's similarity to a security. Under the rating system, a 1 constitutes a crypto asset with few functional similarities to a security, while a 5 would be consistent with the definition of a security.
As of now, the council has rated 20 crypto assets, with the top cryptocurrency by market cap, bitcoin, rated a 1. Notably, XRP, and polymath (POLY) landed scores of 4 or 4.5.
The Crypto Rating Council says the rating system – which it stresses is not investment advice – is based on past SEC guidance and case law, and the legal and technical experience of the firms making up the group.
'Complex' rules
The Blockchain Association's Kristin Smith told CoinDesk that Coinbase originally spearheaded the initiative.
“[It's] an effort by the industry to comply with the incredibly complex [U.S.] securities laws,” Smith said.
For now, only tokens listed by exchanges participating in the council have been rated and released, with more to follow. Assets that receive a 5 may never be disclosed by the Council, Smith told CoinDesk. All assets' assessments are liable to change, Coinbase's blog cautioned.
Coinbase Chief Legal Officer Brian Brooks later clarified to CoinDeks that the Council would not disclose 5 ratings – since member exchanges would not service these assets.
"Since a 5 rating indicates that the asset can only be listed on a registered securities exchange or ATS, by definition those ratings wouldn't be published because the relevant assets aren't listed by any member," Brooks told CoinDesk.
If council members later get approved to operate ATS platforms by regulators like FINRA, that may change, he added.
However, CEO of the Binance exchange, Changpeng "CZ" Zhao, was skeptical of the new ratings system, saying on Twitter:
The guys who score above 2 should form their own counsel and re-rate everything again.
— CZ Binance (@cz_binance) September 30, 2019
The council’s formation comes on the heels of payment network Ripple’s motion to dismiss a lawsuit of its XRP cryptocurrency. Ripple said in its filing that XRP is not a security, though this was not a core argument in its motion to dismiss.
Coinbase CEO Brian Armstrong image via CoinDesk archives
More For You
What to know:
- As of October 2025, GoPlus has generated $4.7M in total revenue across its product lines. The GoPlus App is the primary revenue driver, contributing $2.5M (approx. 53%), followed by the SafeToken Protocol at $1.7M.
- GoPlus Intelligence's Token Security API averaged 717 million monthly calls year-to-date in 2025 , with a peak of nearly 1 billion calls in February 2025. Total blockchain-level requests, including transaction simulations, averaged an additional 350 million per month.
- Since its January 2025 launch , the $GPS token has registered over $5B in total spot volume and $10B in derivatives volume in 2025. Monthly spot volume peaked in March 2025 at over $1.1B , while derivatives volume peaked the same month at over $4B.
More For You
Japan’s Higher Rates Puts Bitcoin in the Crosshairs of a Yen Carry Unwind
A stronger yen typically coincides with de-risking across macro portfolios, and that dynamic could tighten liquidity conditions that recently helped bitcoin rebound from November’s lows.
What to know:
- The Bank of Japan is expected to raise interest rates to 0.75% at its December meeting, the highest since 1995, affecting global markets including cryptocurrencies.
- A stronger yen could lead to de-risking in macro portfolios, impacting liquidity conditions that have supported bitcoin's recent recovery.
- Governor Kazuo Ueda indicated a high probability of a rate hike, with officials prepared for further tightening if their economic outlook supports it.
Top Stories
